Blockchain tech is more mainstream than ever. But on its path to mass adoption, has Web3 shed its idealist, revolutionary roots?


SCENE's 2023 Story of the Year: Is the Web3 Dream Dead?

News
Videos
Gallery
Explorer
Crypties
2023 IN REVIEW

SCENE's 2023 Story of the Year: Is the Web3 Dream Dead?

Blockchain tech is more mainstream than ever. But on its path to mass adoption, has Web3 shed its idealist, revolutionary roots?

By Sander Lutz
Dec 24, 2023
•
6 min read
Image created by Decrypt using AI

Decrypt’s Art, Fashion, and Entertainment Hub.

Discover SCENE

Not so long ago, Web3 was a battle cry. 

00:00


00:00




The term, first coined in 2014 by Ethereum co-founder Gavin Wood to refer to a future, peer-to-peer internet without gatekeepers, gained real vigor during the NFT boom of 2021.
That year, idealistic tech innovators—across art, fashion, journalism, film, hospitality, you name it—adopted Web3 as a coat of arms, one that stood for vanquishing the hyper-centralized powers in control of the global economy, and ushering in a new age of decentralized and democratic prosperity for consumers and creators alike.
AD

By utilizing blockchain technology, these dreamers mused, they could overthrow Hollywood. They could defeat Dolce & Gabbana. They could subdue and push back even the likes of tech giants like Meta. The stakes of this conflict were nothing short of existential: some Web3 industry leaders even likened it to a war against feudal overlords. Web3 startups routinely invoked the rhetoric of struggle and combat—“battle,” “revolution”—to underscore this ethos.

SCENE's Person of the Year: Ghostwriter

In the months following ChatGPT’s seismic debut last November, apocalyptic fears swirled of AI’s potential to destroy almost every human profession imaginable. The entertainment industry ranked high among sectors most preoccupied with AI’s looming threat; but given the stilted, obviously synthetic quality of much GPT-crafted creative output, many assumed that the arts would be—at least for now—a bit more insulated from the impending robot revolution. Then came the anonymous TikTok user hidden b...
Deep Dives

Long Reads

5 min read
Sander Lutz
Dec 14, 2023

But recently, leaders in the Web3 community have begun to openly question whether the revolution has lost its way. 2023, one of crypto’s roughest years ever, was undoubtedly full of sacrifices. To some, those may have included Web3’s founding principles.
“I think what we've seen in Web3 this year is survival being prioritized over ethos,” Dani Loftus, founder of digital fashion platform DRAUP, told Decrypt. “Many [companies] fighting for their lives have compromised the ‘WAGMI’ mentality for whatever metrics make them 'successful' or 'keep them afloat.’ It’s likely the compromises many have made to survive are entrenched.”
The irony is that, at least on paper, Web3 is doing better than ever. From Disney to MoMA to Mercedes to Gucci to Visa to Starbucks, there’s hardly a major Web2 company out there that hasn’t made some kind of Web3 play this year, or internally investigated the possibility.


0 seconds of 8 minutes, 18 seconds

How Adidas Jumped Into Web3 and What It Plans Next

Adidas Web3 lead Erika Wykes-Sneyd told Decrypt's Dan Roberts the story of what prompted Adidas to get into crypto (it involves Elon Musk), what the brand has done so far with NFTs tied to physical apparel, and what it's considering next—including token-gated sneaker drops.
Go to video page

That’s a substantial shift from even two years ago. What’s more, a majority of these companies don’t appear to be one foot out with Web3—many have created years-long roadmaps for their blockchain-backed projects, and established considerable corporate infrastructure to support those endeavors in the long-term.
AD

But while that infusion of support from established companies has bolstered Web3’s prospects this year, it has also come at certain ideological costs. Most Web3 projects taken up by major corporations have not, of course, meaningfully redistributed wealth, influence, or opportunity—-as the technology’s first proponents once sought. 
These projects have instead given birth to new types of customer loyalty programs, exclusive merchandise drops, and product tie-ins. Innovative, surely. But hardly revolutionary in the material sense.  
As for Web3-native startups, many appear to have softened their rhetoric when it comes to the great Web2 enemy. When Apple revealed its immersive mixed reality Vision Pro headset in June, open metaverse advocates—a core subset of the Web3 purist crowd—celebrated the news as a major step forward. 

Did Apple's Headset Reveal Revive the Web3 Metaverse—Or Kill It?

The metaverse was dying. Some said it was already dead. Then along came Apple. On Monday, the tech colossus unveiled its Vision Pro headset, a cutting-edge, immersive mixed reality device the company claims will single-handedly usher in a new age of “spatial computing.” In its exhaustive, meticulously staged, 46 minute roll-out of the device, Apple did not once use the term “metaverse.” It made no reference to the blockchain, nor did it delve into the Vision Pro’s compatibility with tokenized...
Deep Dives

Long Reads

8 min read
Sander Lutz
Jun 8, 2023

These were the same people who, months prior, had declared open war against Meta for trying to dominate the metaverse with corporate imperatives. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, at least, tried to frame his Web3 ambitions with gentle overtures to the open metaverse crowd; Apple’s attitude towards Web3 could be described as unfeeling at best, hostile at worst.
So has Web3 dropped its weapons? Has it left the insurgency behind to join the ranks of the status quo?
Nihar Neelakanti, an entrepreneur who co-founded the blockchain-backed carbon emissions startup Ecosapiens, ascribes much of this recent change of tune within Web3 to the brutal shift that occurred in the fundraising landscape over the last year. 
“I've been in startups my whole life, and VC prior to this,” Neelakanti told Decrypt. “I’ve never heard an investor ask a seed, Series A, or Series B company to seek profitability. Until now.”
“That’s not how startups work,” he continued. “That’s ludicrous to ask of a seed [or] Series A. It's even harder when you're a Web3 company.”
AD

A Digital Fashion House Partners With Meta. Should We Celebrate or Mourn?

Meta, formerly Facebook, announced last week it would begin selling virtual clothing made by DRESSX in its Avatar Store. The news signified a watershed moment for digital fashion houses. Until last week, only three labels—Prada, Balenciaga, and Thom Browne, all storied brands of the physical realm—had been invited by the social media giant to create digital wearables for metaverse avatars. For the first time, a digital-native fashion company had a seat at the table—a table built by the most colo...
News

Business

7 min read
Sander Lutz
Jul 27, 2022

Neelakanti says he’s encountered a complete exhaustion of patience from VC firms with crypto-related companies following events like the collapse of FTX last November. Investors now want immediate returns on their investments, Neelakanti says—which means Web3 companies no longer have the luxury of pursuing high-minded goals like reshaping consumer habits or educating users on the benefits of decentralization. They need to make money—now.
For most struggling Web3 startups, the most feasible path to black has been selling services to established brands and companies—which, Neelakanti said, have zero interest in revolutionizing anything besides their bottom line, and expressly want nothing to do with terms like “crypto,” “NFT,” or “metaverse.”
“People at these companies are saying [to Web3 startups], ‘If I mention the word NFT or Web3, my boss is gonna fucking shoot me,’” Neelakanti said. 

Don’t Call It ‘Crypto’: How Some Blockchain and NFT Projects are Rebranding

It’s the technology that dare not speak its name. Are you looking for NFTs on Reddit or Instagram? You’ll have much better luck searching for “digital collectibles” instead. Remember when blockchain was briefly sexy? The Bitcoin mining firm formerly known as Riot Blockchain recently rebranded itself as Riot Platforms. The World Economic Forum’s head of blockchain and digital assets, Brynly Llyr, has even suggested that the crypto space rebrand itself entirely around “decentralized systems.” “For...
Deep Dives

Long Reads

6 min read
Stephen Graves
Feb 25, 2023

That brings things full circle. It’s not just that harsh financial realities turned Web3 startups’ once-enemies into their best chance at survival. They’ve also forced these startups to often swallow their ideological principles in the name of living another day.
Emma-Jane MacKinnon-Lee, the founder of digital fashion startup Digitalax, identifies the Web3 ecosystem’s current dependence on venture capital as the chief obstacle to the sector realizing its revolutionary potential.
“We can’t have any third-party player able to yank us around by controlling the chokepoints,” she told Decrypt. “That means making VC obsolete before Web3 is finally viable.”

2022 Was Supposed to Be the Year of the Metaverse. What Went Wrong?

Billy Huang runs a metaverse advertising agency. Well, he definitely runs an advertising agency. And not so long ago, that agency did attract a suite of established brands hungry to cash in on the untold potential of the internet’s newest, immersive, virtual frontier. But given the year’s events, Huang’s now thinking about dropping the “m” word. “Maybe now that the metaverse terminology has died down, we do need a little bit of rebranding,” Huang told Decrypt. Huang’s firm, Insomnia Labs, spe...
Deep Dives

Long Reads

9 min read
Sander Lutz
Dec 19, 2022

So Web3 now finds itself going through a bit of a coming-of-age transition—from an idealist’s adolescence into the tough streets of the real world. Balancing the technology’s democratizing potential with tangible profitability was always going to be a high-wire act, but 2023’s ruthless economic realities appear to have pushed things to a head sooner than many expected. 
Not everyone in the space sees things so decidedly black-and-white, though. J.P. Alanis, an entertainment executive who co-founded StoryCo, a Web3 platform for creating and participating in immersive, film-like experiences, says he never sought to burn down Hollywood.