Exploring Bitcoin ETFs: Spot vs. Futures and Their Impact

5 Dec 2023

Bitcoin ETFs have become one of the hottest topics in the crypto industry today. These exchange-traded funds allow mainstream investors to gain exposure to bitcoin through traditional brokerage accounts rather than dealing with digital wallets and exchanges. Many believe bitcoin ETFs can significantly expand adoption and provide stability to the historically volatile asset.

The SEC faces immense pressure around approving a spot bitcoin ETF which tracks the price of actual bitcoin compared to a futures-based ETF that follows bitcoin futures contracts. These two kinds of funds have vastly different implications for investor objectives around risk, tax efficiency, reflecting true price discovery and influence on underlying crypto markets.

As the SEC decides which version will trade first in the US, investors deserve clarity on key contrasts between spot and futures bitcoin ETFs.

Mechanisms Behind Bitcoin Spot & Futures ETFs

While headlines lump these products together as bitcoin ETFs, major structural differences separate spot and futures-backed versions - from physical backing to niche exposures and heightened risk profiles.

First, examine what enables direct spot price exposure...

Bitcoin Spot ETFs

A spot bitcoin ETF directly holds bitcoin itself on investors’ behalf, providing direct price exposure and ownership. The SEC has yet to approve any spot bitcoin ETF in the US due to concerns around custody and potential manipulation. If approved, many experts believe spot bitcoin ETFs open crypto investing to hundreds of millions of new mainstream investors given convenience and trusted consumer protections lacking on cryptocurrency exchanges.

Prominent asset managers like Ark Invest, VanEck and Galaxy Digital maintain long-running SEC applications for spot bitcoin ETFs as “pure play” options tracking real BTC priced via major spot exchanges. Other high-profile institutional investors like Fidelity offer spot bitcoin exposure via trusts tied to the world’s largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization rather than through an ETF wrapper.

Operationally, authorized participants or institutional traders create shares of a spot bitcoin ETF by depositing actual bitcoin they purchased from exchanges or OTC desks into custodial wallets held by the fund manager. The ETFsponsor purchases each bitcoin deposit for fund shares priced precisely to the real-time spot price across leading exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken less small management fees. The process works in reverse for redeeming fund shares back to physical bitcoin assets by authorized participants. For this mechanism to work securely at scale, SEC regulators scrutinize everything from custody and insurance policies to trading protocols and proof of reserves before granting approval.

Thus far no spot bitcoin ETF proposal satisfies all SEC requirements with Grayscale’s Bitcoin Trust instead functioning as the closest existing proxy despite management fees over 2%. Still most experts consider it inevitable for a spot bitcoin ETF to eventually trade in the US as the most direct and efficient means for passive public investment into real decentralized bitcoin.

Now contrast the above to futures-based bitcoin ETF which just began trading...

Bitcoin Futures ETFs 

While spot bitcoin ETFs hold bitcoin itself, a futures ETF provides exposure to bitcoin futures contracts, financial derivatives tracking expected future price movements. Given less direct exposure to physical bitcoin prices, futures ETFs sidestep the custody and manipulation challenges blocking spot ETFs so far.

The first US bitcoin futures ETF called BITO began trading in October 2021 based on bitcoin futures contracts from the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, the world’s largest derivatives exchange. Several other issuers like Valkyrie received SEC approval for futures-backed ETFs as well using CME futures tracking.

Here’s how they operate: institutional authorized participants acquire bitcoin futures contracts at market prices on CME rather than buying spot bitcoin itself. To create shares, APs transfer futures contracts to the ETF manager who calculates share values based on those derivatives prices inclusive of varying risk premiums. The ETF portfolio mixes monthly and quarterly futures expiration contracts to maintain continual market exposure as derivatives expire, a methodology called rolling. The frequent contract rolling necessary to maintain futures positions results in complex tax treatments discussed later. 

In addition to CME futures tracking, several filers propose ETF formats using bitcoin derivatives contracts from cryptocurrency exchanges like Binance, FTX and Bitfinex. These exchange-traded products directly expose investors to unregulated crypto derivatives markets increasing risk concerns.

So in summary - spot bitcoin ETFs provide direct ownership of bitcoin itself priced from underlying spot exchanges. Bitcoin futures ETFs instead track futures contracts one-step removed from physical BTC prices and saddled with structural deficiencies compared to spot market vehicles.

With mechanics established, next assess ideal users of each ETF type...

Who Stands to Benefit?

Now that you understand the structural contrasts between spot and futures bitcoin ETFs, the next crucial question becomes - who stands to benefit most from each kind of fund? As with most financial products in history, the optimal user depends greatly on desired investor objectives.

Types of investors ideally suited to spot vs futures ETFs:


  • Long-term cryptocurrency investors
  • Mainstream investors new to crypto
  • Index fund and passive investors
  • Retail retirement account holders
  • Active traders and speculators
  • Professional fund managers
  • Institutional & high net worth investors
  • Investors requiring liquidity

Starting with the right column above, bitcoin futures ETF likely best serves:

Active Traders & Speculators - The intense volatility associated with futures positions attracts active traders who profit from aggressive short-term bets on price movements in either direction. Futures contracts allow utilizing leverage for maximizing profits as well - albeit with significant risk.

Institutional Investors - Large investment pools like hedge funds and endowments focusing on absolute returns uncorrelated to mainstream assets. Bitcoin futures present trading opportunities surrounding events like Bitcoin halving cycles or global financial instability.

Professional Fund Managers - Sophisticated fund managers well-versed in risk management who package futures ETFs into balanced portfolios to hedge against factors like inflation or diversify asset classes.

Now contrast those users to groups standing to benefit most from SEC approval of spot bitcoin ETF vehicles: 

Long-term Crypto Investors - Spot ETFs enable seamlessly integrating bitcoin into diversified long-term investment portfolios with cost averaging strategies while avoiding burdens of self-custody through retirement accounts like IRAs.

Mainstream Investors New to Crypto - Convenience of passive fractional ownership of real bitcoin through trusted brokerage account frameworks lacks intimidation factor of dealing with exchanges directly for the crypto-curious.

Index & Passive Investors - Passive investment vehicles tracking broad cryptocurrency indexes become significantly more accessible to mass affluent investors through spot ETFs.

Retail Retirement Account Holders - Spot bitcoin ETFs unlock the ability to securely hold bitcoin for retirement savings and apply associated tax advantages. This benefit alone may supercharge bitcoin mainstream adoption more than any other factor the asset has known thus far according to some financial analysts.

With the ideal user groups distinguished, now dive deeper into five key dimensions where spot and futures vehicles differ most...

Spot vs Futures ETFs: Five Key Differentiators

While both ETF wrappers offer exchange-traded convenience accessing crypto markets, major contrasts emerge between spot and futures vehicles when examining dimensions like risk, taxes, fees, price tracking and impact on underlying bitcoin price discovery.

Let’s break down advantages and disadvantages of each across these crucial evaluation criteria. The matrix below summarizes the key categories for comparison:

Category for Comparison Spot Bitcoin ETF Advantages Futures Bitcoin ETF Disadvantages

Pricing and Tracking • Precise mirroring of bitcoin prices via direct ownership • Weak correlation to physical BTC prices
Volatility and Risk • Inherits market volatility of bitcoin spot price • Amplified volatility via leverage inherent in futures
Tax Treatment • More favorable 60/40 tax rule benefit • Complex taxation via constant rolling
Fees and Expenses • Expense ratios under 1% • Higher expense ratios near 2%

Impact on Bitcoin Market • May directly influence spot price • Limited price impact on underlying bitcoin

Now examine the key differences across those vital evaluation points:

  1. Pricing & Tracking of Underlying Bitcoin Perhaps the greatest investor benefit spot ETFs hold over futures comes down to precisely tracking the price of actual bitcoin itself in real-time through direct ownership. This allows efficiently gaining exposure identical to owning bitcoin outright without complexities of custody.

In contrast, even physically-settled bitcoin futures contracts trade at varying premiums to spot price based on associated carry costs and speculation. This deviation persists because no immediate delivery of bitcoin occurs - you must hold the contract to full expiration to take delivery rather than owning the asset directly. Complicating matters further, futures bitcoin ETFs like BITO utilize a mix of monthly and quarterly contracts blending various expiration dates constantly rolling over for seamless market exposure. This rolling methodology together with persistent futures premiums over spot prices leads to significant and unpredictable tracking error compared to bitcoin’s actual market price.

So in summary, spot bitcoin ETFs closely track real BTC pricing due to direct ownership while futures ETFs deviate unpredictably due to derivatives premiums and rolling methodologies - although sophisticated investors can strategically utilize the segmentation of spot and futures pricing when opportunities arise.

  1. Volatility Profile and Risk In financial markets, leverage constitutes a double-edged sword - multiplying gains during upswings yet exacerbating losses on downside moves. And given the plenty of inherent leverage associated with derivatives contracts driving futures ETFs, these funds tend to demonstrate significantly higher volatility compared to spot market vehicles. The increased volatility holds potential for amplifying profits but suffers swollen risk profiles.

Since spot bitcoin ETF proposals custody actual bitcoin as collateral, they inherit the same volatility attributes of BTC itself without derivatives leverage supercharging price swings. So while bitcoin exhibits high natural volatility due to current low market capitalization relative to potential, spot ETFs likely demonstrate lower volatility on balance compared to turbocharged futures counterparts - especially during periods of downward pricing.

Thus futures ETFs appeal most to risk-seeking speculators comfortable weathering the intense volatility while long-term investors typically favor reduced fluctuations holding BTC outright through spot ETFs.

  1. Tax Treatment
  2. Taxes also differ substantially between futures and physically-backed funds due to implications surrounding the "constructive sale rule” which stipulates investors must recognize any gains whenever an asset gets sold, even if proceeds get reinvested in substantially identical holdings.

This matters crucially for futures funds because the methodology utilized known as roll yield constantly closes out soon-to-expire contracts by reinvesting in longer-dated futures to maintain continual bitcoin market exposure. This perpetual process incurs tax liabilities upon selling each monthly contract prior to expiry to roll into newer quarterly contracts. Based on the 60/40 tax rule, these triggered gains tax at the higher short-term capital gains rate up to nearly 40% federally given enough contract turnover selling rather than lower long-term 15-20% rates.

In contrast, buying and holding actual bitcoin for over a year provides preferential long-term capital gains treatment. And a spot bitcoin ETF owning real BTC avoids tax events stemming from futures roll yield, allowing investors to cost average over long durations. For large investment pools concerned over taxes, spot bitcoin ETFs compare very favorably to cumbersome futures vehicles.

  1. Fees and Expenses Investors also care deeply about minimizing fees denting net returns. Funds disclosing lower expense ratios keep more gains in investor pockets rather than sponsors.

And given management fees for existing bitcoin futures ETFs approach almost 2% while Grayscale’s spot Bitcoin Trust charges over 2% annually, room for improvement exists regarding wrap fund costs for crypto vehicles. In contrast, several spot bitcoin ETF applications like Ark Invest’s offer expense ratios priced below 1% - in line with mainstream equity index funds like those tracking the S&P 500 at 0.03%.

If spot bitcoin ETFs earn approval, their lower fee structures combined with tax advantages from avoiding roll yield may position these funds as the class of choice for long-term crypto investors seeking to minimize expenses.

  1. Impact on Underlying Bitcoin Market A final but often overlooked differentiator involves the influence approved ETFs wield over prevailing bitcoin prices in underlying spot markets. Economists expect a spot bitcoin ETF to directly guide institutional capital injections into real BTC itself - influencing price discovery dynamics significantly more compared to indirect futures funds producing little direct impact on cryptocurrency itself.

The basis for this expectation simply reflects where inflows accumulate for each vehicle. As covered earlier, inflows into a spot ETF require ongoing purchases of actual bitcoin to collateralize additional share creation. This growing demand flows directly into physical BTC spot markets, impacting real-time supply and demand dynamics that determine cryptocurrencies’ ever-important prices.

On the other hand, institutional inflows into bitcoin futures ETFs simply absorb more derivatives contracts without directly influencing spot bitcoin holdings or pricing due to that degree of separation.

So while futures ETFs currently trade in the US market, economists predict approval of spot bitcoin ETFs holds potential to spur the greatest acceleration of institutional bitcoin adoption and spot price impact in the asset’s brief history.

The Great Bitcoin ETF Debate Resolved...?

Meanwhile direct ownership of physical bitcoin itself using SEC-approved channels offers the holy grail for mass cryptocurrency adoption - resolving custody and manipulation hurdles blocking prudent mainstream and retirement investor participation until now.

Nevertheless, both ETF structures attract growing billions in assets under management daily. This trend substantially expands access to digital asset exposure regardless of format imperfections in these inaugural products certain to see innovation and improvement over successive generations.

Thank you for reading! If you found this content valuable, please consider supporting my work

SOLANA : 5tGG8ausWWo8u9K1brb2tZQEKuDMZ9C6kUD1e96dkNBo
TRX and TRX USDT : TMtuDzU9XE5HHi83PZphujxSFiiDzyUVkA
BITCOIN : bc1qehnkue20nce3zgec73qvmhy0g3zak69l24y06g
Flow Address: 0xc127a6d0990af587
XRP : rGzWnVNpecRVqzb95pWvGxqUY8DpSTGATT
ADA: addr1qx026lu93l7nj229alh0qcf2e69fx0selxmm870f80h9uzsgze4den3cvq337q65esfgw8t5zttfvkm6j6fljjsh00cqca3nqx
BCH : qpvs92cgn0722lwsraaumczj3dznpvclkv70knp0sn
LTC : ltc1qq0jp3xj5vmjwm57lr6339xhp8sf6c3lq9fv3ye
MNT : 0x17c81f1cb85B5B563a4dd667C23b237e79bAae86
ATOM : cosmos1dvvn0p4dgdtzjh9eudy2gcrcys0efhd2ldhyvs
FIL : f1fj3atuusz5ftguoikwcv7i7x3zkzzplgsi6jyki
DOGE : D6fe2wFy4EgwTi3Rv74qooBRijXeyBTHpb
APT : 0x5a82df18a80ee52c50c3bcd7116faf4ccf953d21c791e8934b8acea87aa1f774
NEAR : bd60d76219f6dee11156d254a7d228730bc4204d73603778c5ff18d82c83e398
TEZOS XTZ : tz1bMZwPB8x8aRv5tLxHmQ3q8Auy1RFMhtPH
ICP : wbak4-ujyhn-jtb4f-gyddm-jkpwu-viujq-7jwe3-wl3ck-azbpz-gy45g-tqe

Write & Read to Earn with BULB

Learn More

Enjoy this blog? Subscribe to CapitalThink


No comments yet.
Most relevant comments are displayed, so some may have been filtered out.