Learn about veTokens and veTokenomics.

5tGG...kNBo
24 Oct 2023
81

VeTokens are a new type of digital asset that is gaining popularity in the world of decentralized finance (DeFi). VeTokens stand for value-encoding tokens and represent an evolution beyond cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum.

Whereas cryptocurrencies have a fixed supply and their value comes mainly from speculation, veTokens are designed to hold and reflect underlying real-world assets like fiat currencies, commodities, real estate, debt, equity or revenue streams from businesses. This gives veTokens intrinsic value beyond pure speculation.

VeTokenomics refers to the design and issuance model for veTokens. Well-designed veTokenomics are essential to ensure the veTokens reliably hold their value and benefit all stakeholders in the system. This includes factors like token supply, valuation mechanisms, incentive alignment and governance processes.

The Evolution from Cryptocurrencies to veTokens


Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum represented a revolutionary decentralized digital asset when they launched over a decade ago. However, after the initial hype and speculation, limitations have emerged in using cryptocurrencies as actual currencies or stores of value.

Cryptocurrencies lack any intrinsic backing, so their valuation is purely driven by speculation. This leads to high volatility, which prevents them from holding stable value. Their fixed supply is also not responsive to economic conditions and demand for currency in the real world.

These limitations have prevented cryptocurrencies from seriously competing with fiat currencies like the US Dollar for everyday payments and transactions. Most of the actual usage remains speculative trading and investment.

VeTokens aim to solve these issues by maintaining the decentralization and security of blockchain-based cryptocurrencies, while introducing intrinsic valuation mechanisms backed by real financial assets. This gives veTokens stable value over the long-term by tying them to real world assets, while still allowing convertibility and transferability across the blockchain.

The idea is to create an asset that combines the strengths of both fiat currencies and cryptocurrencies, acting as a bridge between decentralized digital assets and the traditional financial world. Well-designed veTokens and veTokenomics have the potential to unlock unique benefits.

Benefits and Use Cases of veTokens


Here are some of the key benefits and potential use cases of veTokens:

  • Stable value - VeTokens can hold stable value in the long run by tying to real-world assets like fiat currencies, commodities, real estate and financial contracts. This makes them viable for everyday payments and a store of value, unlike highly volatile cryptocurrencies.
  • Decentralized - VeTokens allow creating decentralized stablecoins and digital assets, reducing reliance on central intermediaries like banks. But they maintain ties to the real economy.
  • Programmable - By being on the blockchain, veTokens inherit programmability features like smart contracts. This enables financial transactions and products not possible otherwise.
  • Embedded governance - On-chain governance mechanisms can be baked into veTokens, aligning incentives between stakeholders and facilitating collective decision making.
  • Regulatory clarity - VeTokens directly linked to regulated real-world assets can operate within existing legal frameworks much more easily.
  • Mainstream adoption - The asset backing and familiar structure of veTokens makes them easily comprehensible to mainstream users beyond just tech enthusiasts.
  • Trade finance - VeTokens can enable fractional ownership and trading of assets like real estate, commodities and invoices that were previously illiquid and inaccessible.
  • Fan engagement - Sports teams, esports teams and content creators can issue veTokens to tap into fanbases and allow new monetization models based on sharing revenue streams.
  • Decentralized finance - Stable-value veTokens avoid volatility risks and unlock unique decentralized financial products involving loans, derivatives, insurance and more.


This wide range of use cases makes veTokens potentially disruptive across many sectors like financial services, trade finance, real estate, entertainment, retail, supply chain and more. Well-designed veTokens tailored for specific applications can provide massive value.

Key Design Principles for VeTokens


For veTokens to properly achieve their potential benefits, they need to be carefully designed around some key principles:

  • Maintain intrinsic value - The veToken needs clear legal and technical mechanisms to hold its intrinsic value. This depends on the asset backing like fiat currencies, commodities etc. Proper controls and governance procedures need to enforce this.
  • Allow price discovery - While maintaining long-term intrinsic value, the veToken should have some ability for price discovery on exchanges. This allows flexibility and trading capabilities. The degree depends on use case.
  • Enshrine rights - Rights like ownership, voting, access, dividends or revenue shares need to be encoded properly into veTokens. This gives token holders proper incentives.
  • Provide utility - Beyond just financial value, well-designed veTokens give additional utility like access privileges, governance rights, discounts etc. This creates long-term demand.
  • Honor claims - Redemption processes and legal structures need to guarantee veToken holders can honor claims underlying assets when required. This ensures confidence.
  • Minimize volatility - VeToken designs should aim to minimize speculative volatility by incentivizing long-term holding and utilizing tools like stabilization funds and trading fees.
  • Maintain transparency - Token issuers need to ensure proper transparency on assets backing tokens, changes in value, governance mechanisms and other factors influencing value.
  • Enable liquidity - Secondary markets and sufficient liquidity need to be enabled so veToken holders can exit positions. Market making and incentivized external arbitrageurs can assist here.
  • Implement controls - Proper controls need to be in place like KYC, reserve audits, supply caps, governance processes and legal contracts to ensure the intrinsic value holds.


A well-designed veToken needs to strike the right balance across these principles to align incentives and provide benefits to all stakeholders involved.

Technical Implementations of VeTokens


There are a few key technical approaches to implementing veTokens on a blockchain:

Fiat/Asset Collateralized Stablecoins

This is the most direct approach adopted by early veTokens like Tether. Here tokens are issued representing an underlying fiat currency like US Dollars held in reserves by the issuer. 100 Tether tokens are issued for every $100 held in bank reserves.

The token is pegged to the fiat currency and in theory redeemable 1 to 1 directly for the reserves. Holders pay USD to mint new tokens, burning tokens returns USD.

Crypto Collateralized Stablecoins

Holding large fiat reserves has challenges for decentralized systems. So projects like MakerDAO instead collateralize tokens with other cryptocurrencies like Ethereum.

Users deposit say $150 worth of ETH into smart contracts to mint $100 worth of tokens to maintain collateral ratios. If ETH drops, some ETH can be sold to maintain the peg. Excess collateral protects against volatility.

Asset Backed Tokens

This model is for veTokens representing assets beyond just fiat currencies. The tokens can represent real estate, invoices, commodities, renewable energy credits, shares in a company etc.

The issuers legally bind the tokens to fractional ownership of the underlying asset class. This aligns incentives to maintain intrinsic value. Secondary markets can enable trading.

Algorithmic Stablecoins

These try to maintain stable value via an algorithm instead of actual assets. Holders and issuers can programmatically buy and sell tokens responding to supply and demand to stabilize the price.

It relies heavily on game theory and well-calibrated algorithms. Requires sophisticated design and subject to instability risks.

Hybrid Approaches

Many veToken implementations use hybrid models combining features like collateralization, asset backing, smart contract controls, algorithms and programmed incentives. This balances tradeoffs for decentralization, volatility and liquidity.

The optimal technical design depends on the specific veToken use case and needs. But all models rely on careful tokenomics to incentivize behavior that maintains intrinsic value.

Valuation Models and Pricing Mechanisms


VeTokens need robust valuation models to properly link the token value to their underlying real-world assets. Two main valuation models are:

Collateralized Value

Used for reserve/collateral backed tokens pegged to assets like fiat currency. The token value = collateral reserves denominated in the currency/asset. Maintained via arbitrage.

Fractional Value

For direct fractional ownership in assets. Token Value = (Total Asset Value x Ownership Percentage)/Total Tokens

Ownership percentage can be fixed like 1 token = 0.001% of the asset. Or adjustable based on token ratios.

These valuations need to have prices and exchange rates that are transparently tracked and supplied to exchanges. This allows trading and price discovery aligned to fundamentals.

Some mechanisms used are:

  • Order book exchanges for direct price discovery
  • Periodic auctions to determine clearing prices
  • Pegging token value to API published indices as reference data
  • Allowing authorized market makers for reliably supplying pricing
  • Algorithmic central bank mechanisms that regulate supply and attempt to stabilize pricing.


The ideal model maintains long-term intrinsic value alignment while providing sufficient liquidity and transparent market pricing.

Approaches to Decentralized Governance


An important aspect of veTokens is implementing decentralized governance over factors that influence the token value. Some dimensions on which governance is required:

  • Changing underlying asset allocation
  • Adding collateral assets
  • Adjusting stability mechanisms and parameters
  • Listing on exchanges
  • Adding liquidity pools and market makers
  • Burning/minting token supply
  • Protocol upgrades
  • Dispute resolution
  • Financial audits


For transparency and aligning incentives, governance power should be distributed across different stakeholders like:

  • Token holders - Can vote on decisions weighted by proportional ownership to align incentives
  • Issuers and reserve managers - Have certain privileges to ensure system stability and maintenance
  • External arbitrators - Experts that help resolve disputes between parties via subject matter expertise
  • Core development team - Granted certain powers to upgrade software and fix bugs without being obstructed
  • Legal board - Granted oversight powers to ensure compliance with regulations. Can veto proposals by other parties.


Different projects take different approaches here. MakerDAO lets MKR holders vote. Reserve Protocol uses a stablecoin called RSV for voting. Synthetix grants holders of SNX token voting powers.

But in general, the goal is to align voting powers with the incentives of stakeholders that are long-term aligned with maintaining the token value.

Granting privileged roles to certain stakeholders like core developers and legal overseers helps balance decentralized control with practical maintenance needs.

Token Distribution and Incentive Alignment


Token distribution and incentivization models are critical for veTokens. Broadly, tokens can either be issued via:

  • Pre-minted supply - Tokens minted directly by project creators as a fixed supply.
  • Minted on-demand - Tokens continually minted based on demand and collateral deposited


Most projects use a hybrid approach issuing an initial supply but allowing further minting. The initial distribution/sale serves to:

  • Raise funds for development
  • Seed network effects with users
  • Provide anchor pricing for market discovery
  • Distribute governance rights across stakeholders


Ongoing minting responds to user demand but must be controlled to avoid compromising value. Some control mechanisms include:

  • Limiting supply growth rate
  • Imposing collateral requirements
  • Charging variable minting fees
  • Establishing waiting periods
  • Placing access limits


Well calibrated supply controls aligned with user incentives are critical to maintaining long-term value.

In terms of incentives, veToken creators typically retain portion of the supply for themselves to benefit from network growth. But distributing majority widely creates incentive alignment and stake in governance.

Users can be incentivized to stake tokens in collateral pools in return for yield. External arbitrageurs and market makers can be subsidized for creating liquidity. Holders who vote and participate in governance can earn rewards.

Aligning incentives across all actors involved in the system is key to keeping veTokens attractive and maintaining equilibrium.

Risks to be Managed with VeTokens


While veTokens have disruptive potential, designing them well requires carefully navigating some key risks:

Collateral and reserve risks - Reserves could be mismanaged. Collateral ratios may become imbalanced. Controls need to prevent this.
Liquidity risks - Insufficient liquidity prevents token redemption. Essential to maintain active markets and authorized market makers.
Governance risks - Bad governance can lead to poor decisions compromising value. Distributed governance is complex to implement right.
Technological risks - Bugs, hacks, and failures could disrupt veToken operations. Rigorous audits and testing is crucial.
Financial risks - The underlying assets and collateral might experience market volatility or lose value directly compromising veTokens.
Regulatory risks - Evolving regulations impose legal uncertainty. Compliance needs to be proactively monitored.
Business risks - Bad business decisions like partnering with the wrong centralized exchanges can affect adoption.
Network risks - Low user adoption and lack of network effects can prevent sufficient liquidity and activity.

By thoroughly evaluating these risks, designers can develop mechanisms that mitigate downsides through governance controls, smart contract logic, incentive alignment, legal compliance, asset selection, key partnerships, technology security and built-in system redundancies.

Example VeToken Projects


Many exciting veToken projects are emerging using the principles we’ve discussed. Here are some major examples:

MakerDAO and DAI

MakerDAO is a decentralized finance protocol that allows users to lock up crypto as collateral via smart contracts to mint new DAI stablecoins pegged to $1 USD. It has grown to become the largest DeFi protocol with billions in locked collateral.

Dai aims to maintain its peg through collateralization, autonomous feedback mechanisms and incentivized external actors. It has proven robust over multiple market cycles.

Reserve Protocol and Reserve Rights

Reserve Protocol takes a decentralized bank approach using a two token model. Reserve Rights tokens allow holders to vote on critical parameters governing Reserve - a stablecoin that adjusts supply to maintain its peg to $1.

Reserve uses algorithms and incentives to provide stability and is backed by a basket of other crypto assets.

Synthetix and Synths

Synthetix allows users to mint and exchange Synths, which are synthetic assets that track the value of real-world assets like currencies, commodities, stocks and indices. It uses SNX tokens as collateral to back Synths.

This provides exposure to a range of assets via decentralized and trustless derivatives on Ethereum. Yield is provided for SNX stakers to incentivize collateralization.

Celo and Celo Dollars

Celo is a mobile-focused DeFi ecosystem using Celo Dollars, a stablecoin designed to empower financial inclusion and make DeFi accessible for anyone with a smartphone.

It uses a reserve-backed model with basket of crypto and commodities. The focus has been usability, quick transactions and building an ecosystem of real world mobile apps.

Gala Games and Townstar

Gala Games builds play-to-earn blockchain games. Townstar is a flagship farming game where in-game rewards are powered by the ERC-20 GALA governance token and TownCoin stablecoin pegged to USD value.

This demonstrates using veTokens for new community-driven gaming monetization models.
These demonstrate the remarkable range and diversity emerging in veToken designs tailored to different contexts.

The Future Outlook for VeTokens and veTokenomics


VeTokens are still in their early days, but have massive disruptive potential across numerous industries. As the designs and surrounding infrastructure matures, here are some expected trends:

  • Next-gen decentralized finance - Stable-value veTokens will enable more sophisticated DeFi products mirroring traditional finance
  • Disintermediating venture capital and real estate - VeTokens provide liquidity unlocking new models for investing in startups and physical assets
  • Fan engagement in entertainment - Media creators leveraging veTokens to share value with fans and form deeper connections
  • Evolution of global trade - VeTokens can provide enforceability, automation and asset traceability to make trade finance more efficient
  • Mainstream adoption - Onramps from fiat will improve and integrations with existing payment platforms will arise, taking stable veTokens mainstream
  • Regulatory clarity - Standards will emerge around veTokens tied to regulated assets like fiat currencies and securities, providing legal assurance
  • Self-sovereign identity - VeTokens will allow sharing attested claims about identity attributes in a permissionless yet trusted manner
  • Corporate treasuries - VeTokens will become a tool for efficient treasury management and liquidity for companies
  • Interoperability - Cross-chain protocols and token bridges will enable value transfer across different blockchain veToken platforms
  • IoT machine economies - VeTokens will allow monetization models between automated systems like self-driving cars, bots, drones and smart appliances.
  • New crypto-native products and services - Entirely novel applications will emerge that can only exist by combining veToken economics with blockchain programmability.


As veTokens start embedding themselves across all these domains and more, entire new ecosystems and economies could develop powered by decentralized trustless value transfer and exchange. Just as the early internet enabled information exchange in unforeseen ways, veTokens have the potential to unlock new modes of value exchange we can only scarcely imagine today.

Conclusion

VeTokens represent the next evolution in blockchain-based digital assets by moving beyond speculative cryptocurrencies to create programmable digital money with reliable value.

The core concepts of veTokens are still being actively researched and developed. But the initial experiments demonstrate their vast potential to build decentralized ecosystems that blend the transparency and programmability of blockchains with the stability and predictability of existing financial assets.

For all the risks and challenges involved, veTokens offer a glimpse at the future of finance, economics and value exchange that is more open, accessible, efficient and empowering. As the surrounding infrastructure and designs mature, veTokens could fundamentally reshape how we collectively understand, quantify, exchange and leverage value across society.

Your Support Matters:


SOLANA : 5tGG8ausWWo8u9K1brb2tZQEKuDMZ9C6kUD1e96dkNBo

ETHEREUM/polygon/OP/ARB/FTM/ AVAX/BNB :

0x608E4C17B3f891cAca5496f97c63b55AD2240BB5

BITCOIN : 1LhLn5pVx556hJhyh3jDPLYTyq9BChZ61e

Write & Read to Earn with BULB

Learn More

Enjoy this blog? Subscribe to CapitalThink

5 Comments

B
No comments yet.
Most relevant comments are displayed, so some may have been filtered out.